The rule in one paragraph
The regulation reduces the deduction “(but not below zero) by $200 for each $1,000 (or portion thereof)” by which your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is above $100,000, or above $200,000 on a joint return [1]. The reduction comes off the amount left after the $10,000 cap, not off your full interest. The $200,000 threshold is only for joint returns. Treasury and the IRS confirmed that $100,000 applies to “all other taxpayers, including taxpayers that have a filing status of head of household” [1], and the 2025 IRS instructions list $100,000 for “all other filing statuses” [3].
The basics of who qualifies are in The car loan interest deduction, explained. This guide is only about the arithmetic.
Why $1 can cost $200
“Or portion thereof” means every started $1,000 counts in full. The 2025 Schedule 1-A spells it out on line 28: divide the excess by $1,000, and “if the resulting number isn’t a whole number, increase the result to the next higher whole number. (For example, increase 1.5 to 2, and increase 0.05 to 1.)” [2]
So $50 over the threshold rounds up to one step, and costs $200, exactly as much as $1,000 over. The regulation’s own example rounds 24.2 up to 25 [1].
What counts as MAGI
For an individual, MAGI is adjusted gross income “increased by any amount excluded from gross income under sections 911, 931, or 933” of the tax code: the foreign earned income exclusion and the exclusions for income from Puerto Rico and certain US territories [1]. On the 2025 Schedule 1-A, Part I starts from Form 1040, line 11b, and adds those amounts on lines 2a–2d [2]. Most people have none, so their MAGI is simply line 11b.
Claiming the deduction does not lower the MAGI that sets its own phase-out. The deduction is subtracted from adjusted gross income in computing taxable income [1], and on the return it is entered on Form 1040, line 13b, after line 11b [4].
Example 1: just over the line
Worked example · single filer, $50 over
- Qualifying interest for the year: $4,800. Under the cap, so it stays $4,800.
- MAGI: $100,050. That is $50 over the $100,000 threshold.
- $50 ÷ $1,000 = 0.05, rounded up to 1 step.
- 1 × $200 = $200 reduction.
Deduction: $4,800 − $200 = $4,600 (our arithmetic). At $101,000 it would be the same; at $101,001 it drops to $4,400.
Example 2: two cars on a joint return
Worked example · married filing jointly, cap first
- Qualifying interest: $7,400 on one car and $4,100 on the other, $11,500 in total.
- The cap is $10,000 per return, whatever the filing status [1], so $10,000 goes forward.
- MAGI: $236,900. That is $36,900 over the $200,000 joint threshold.
- $36,900 ÷ $1,000 = 36.9, rounded up to 37 steps.
- 37 × $200 = $7,400 reduction.
Deduction: $10,000 − $7,400 = $2,600 (our arithmetic).
The order matters. Taking the $7,400 off the full $11,500 first would leave $4,100, but the regulation applies the phase-out to the amount “after the application of the dollar limitation” [1], and Schedule 1-A does the same: line 24 caps the total, then line 30 subtracts the reduction from line 24 [2].
Example 3: head of household with excluded income
Worked example · head of household, income from abroad added back
- Form 1040, line 11b: $93,000. Below $100,000 on its own.
- The filer worked abroad for part of the year and excluded $15,000 on Form 2555, which goes on Schedule 1-A, line 2b.
- MAGI: $93,000 + $15,000 = $108,000. Head of household uses the $100,000 threshold, so the excess is $8,000.
- $8,000 ÷ $1,000 = 8 steps, and 8 × $200 = $1,600 reduction.
- Qualifying interest: $3,300, under the cap.
Deduction: $3,300 − $1,600 = $1,700 (our arithmetic). Without the add-back, there would be no reduction at all.
Where each amount runs out
Divide your interest (after the cap) by $200 and round up. That is the number of $1,000 steps that wipe it out. If it takes N steps, the deduction is gone as soon as MAGI is more than (N − 1) × $1,000 above the threshold. Our arithmetic:
| Qualifying interest | Steps to zero | Single, head of household, separate | Joint return |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | 5 | $104,000 | $204,000 |
| $2,500 | 13 | $112,000 | $212,000 |
| $5,000 | 25 | $124,000 | $224,000 |
| $7,500 | 38 | $137,000 | $237,000 |
| $10,000 | 50 | $149,000 | $249,000 |
Check one row: $2,500 of interest at a MAGI of exactly $112,000 is 12 steps, a $2,400 reduction, and $100 left. One dollar more makes it 13 steps and $0.
Questions
Does head of household get a higher threshold?
No. Treasury and the IRS considered it and kept $100,000, because the law sets only two thresholds: $200,000 for joint returns and $100,000 for everyone else.
What if we file married filing separately?
Each separate return uses the $100,000 threshold, and the $10,000 cap applies per return.
Can the phase-out make the deduction negative?
No. It stops at zero. Schedule 1-A, line 30, says to enter zero if the result is zero or less.
Does the deduction lower my own MAGI?
No. It is taken after adjusted gross income, so it never changes the figure the phase-out is measured against.
Run your own numbers. Does My Car Qualify? applies the $10,000 cap and the phase-out, with the rounding, to your interest and MAGI.
Ardesse is not affiliated with the IRS or the Treasury Department. This guide is general information about published rules, not tax advice; the examples are illustrations, and your return and the IRS decide. Last reviewed 2026-11-04.
Sources
- T.D. 10054, 91 FR 57214 (September 8, 2026): 26 CFR §1.163-16(b)(8), (h)(1)–(h)(3), and the preamble on the phase-out thresholds and section 63(b)(7) (PDF) — checked 4 Nov 2026.
- IRS Schedule 1-A (Form 1040) 2025, Part I (lines 1–3) and Part IV (lines 22–30) — checked 4 Nov 2026.
- IRS, 2025 Instructions for Form 1040, Schedule 1-A Part IV, “Maximum amount of deduction” — checked 4 Nov 2026.
- IRS Form 1040 (2025), lines 11b to 15 — checked 4 Nov 2026.